The decision starts with heel height, not color
Lulu Saddle Suede and Josie Chocolate Suede sit close together in tone — both are warm brown suedes — but they are different shoes for different days. Lulu is a pointed flat with a low-profile heel and extra padding. Josie is a pointed court shoe on a 55mm block kitten heel, with padded insoles and a leather lining. If you are choosing between them, the first question is whether you want a flat or a low block heel. The color decision comes second.
Side by side: what each shoe is built for
- Lulu Saddle Suede: Pointed flat in warm brown saddle suede with a low-profile heel and extra padding. Standard fit across the listed sizes. Built for a flat, practical finish to an outfit.
- Josie Chocolate Suede: Pointed court shoe in chocolate suede with a 55mm block kitten heel, padded insoles, leather lining and a natural nubuck sole. Standard fit and wide fit options in selected sizes. Built for a low, stable heel with a dressier line.
What the Lulu Saddle Suede record confirms
- Lulu Saddle Suede: Pointed flat in warm brown saddle suede with a low-profile heel and extra padding. The flat profile and extra padding are the core of the Lulu's comfort case, and the saddle tone is what makes it a neutral.

Lulu Saddle Suede - Lulu Saddle Suede: Available in EU 35–40.5 / UK 2–7.5 / US 5–10.5, all standard fit. The size run stops at EU 40.5, so larger feet may not find a match. All listed variants are standard fit, with no wide fit option shown.
Sizing: both are standard fit, but the size runs differ
Both shoes are listed as standard fit, so the main sizing difference is the range on offer. Lulu Saddle Suede runs from EU 35 to EU 40.5 (UK 2 to UK 7.5, US 5 to US 10.5) in standard fit only. Josie Chocolate Suede runs from EU 36 to EU 42 (UK 3 to UK 9, US 6 to US 12) in standard fit, with selected wide fit sizes from EU 35 to EU 40 (UK 2 to UK 7, US 5 to US 10). If you are at the top of the Lulu range or need a wide fit, Josie is the more likely match. If you are at the smaller end and want a flat, Lulu covers EU 35 and 35.5, which Josie's standard fit does not list.
What the Josie Chocolate Suede record confirms
- Josie Chocolate Suede: 55mm block kitten heel with padded insoles, leather lining and a natural nubuck sole. The block heel is the defining difference from Lulu, and the lining and sole details explain the dressier construction.

Josie Chocolate Suede - Josie Chocolate Suede: Standard fit in EU 36–42 / UK 3–9 / US 6–12, plus wide fit in selected sizes from EU 35–40 / UK 2–7 / US 5–10. The wider size range and the wide fit option make Josie the more flexible choice for fit, especially at the larger end.
Styling each suede shoe
Both are neutral brown suedes, so they work with the same warm palette. The difference is the silhouette and the occasion.
- Lulu Saddle Suede styling: The flat, pointed shape and saddle tone suit tailored trousers, straight-leg jeans and midi skirts. It is the pair to reach for when you want a polished finish without a heel — for a long day, a commute or a relaxed dinner.
- Josie Chocolate Suede outfit: The 55mm block heel and pointed court line make Josie the dressier option. Wear it with a midi dress, a suit or dark denim for events, dinners and work days that call for a little lift. The chocolate suede reads richer and deeper than saddle, so it pairs naturally with navy, black and cream.
The honest trade-offs
Lulu Saddle Suede is the more casual, lower-maintenance-feeling choice in the sense that a flat is easier to walk in, but its size range stops at EU 40.5 and there is no wide fit listed. Josie Chocolate Suede offers a wider size range and a wide fit option, and its block heel is low enough to feel stable, but it is still a heel and not a flat. Neither record includes care instructions, so check the product page or ask the store before treating either suede with any product. If you need a flat and your size is within Lulu's range, Lulu is the straightforward pick. If you want a low heel, a wider fit or a larger size, Josie is the better fit.



